Alla rapporter
Catan rapporter
#74816: "unable to build settlement"
infoneeded: Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel
Vad handlar denna rapport om?
Vad hände? Välj från alternativen nedan
Interfacet har hindrat mig från att utföra en spelhandling som är godkänd enligt reglerna
Detaljerad beskrivning
• Vilken spelhandling ville du göra?
wanted to build a settlement. I had 1 left to build & yet it wasn't an available option. I had 4 settlements & 1 city built at the time• Vad försöker du göra för att sätta igång denna spelmekaniken?
Clicked on build• Vad hände när du försökte göra det här (felmeddelande, meddelande i spelstatusrad, ...)?
No error message, just no option to build a settlement• Vad har du för webbläsare?
Google Chrome v106
Rapporthistorik
29 okt 2022 19:22 • kestrel318 • Buggen har inte kunnat återupprepas av utvecklarna än:
F5 did not solve the problem. I had this happen to an opponent during another game.
29 okt 2022 22:16 • lordalx • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Was there any allowed location to build a settlement ?
29 okt 2022 22:41 • kestrel318 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I didn't have any other places I could build one. This was the only spot I had with 2 roads to it that wasn't blocked. It correctly showed that I had 1 house left in my hand just had no option to place it where I should have been able to.
29 okt 2022 23:03 • lordalx • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Thanks for your feedback
Could you tell when (ie. move number) and where (which tile intersection) you faced this issue ?
Could you tell when (ie. move number) and where (which tile intersection) you faced this issue ?
20 jan 2023 4:59 • HTDream • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I had two available spots to build a settlement, but it was not an option even though i had all the required resources. Refreshing the game did not solve the problem. I was using the BGA app on my tablet. I also checked on my phone and the same thing was happening on my phone. It would only let me build roads.
20 jan 2023 19:12 • HTDream • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Table #338413117
Move #141
Progression 63%
The problem happened several moves ago, and continues throughout the rest of the game. Every turn after continued to prevent me from building a settlement.
Move #141
Progression 63%
The problem happened several moves ago, and continues throughout the rest of the game. Every turn after continued to prevent me from building a settlement.
30 mar 2023 6:12 • boobookittyfrack • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
After the first 2 settlements I was unable to place anymore the interface only offered roads
4 apr 2023 11:36 • boobookittyfrack • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
After initial building phase I was only shown options for roads nothing more no matter how many resources I had
17 maj 2023 2:51 • Anatoly Karpov • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
The problems appeared several times in the game. I couldn''t build settlement on 3 hex several times, despite having all the resources and no settlement nearby.
Have a screenshot but I don't use Imgur.
Have a screenshot but I don't use Imgur.
17 maj 2023 2:52 • Anatoly Karpov • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
5 jul 2023 10:03 • DopamineAddict • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
During initial setup, I cancelled where I wanted to put my second settlement. Then I couldn’t select the available spot to put it on, until my time ran up. This game is not build for iPad or what? I refreshed and could build a settlement but not a road.
24 jul 2023 15:00 • Hartley Ward • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I had the cards required to build a road and it would not let me. Next turn I could build a road but then I couldn’t build a settlement. I ran out of time trying to find a way to achieve it but nothing worked and I was kicked out of the game.
29 jul 2023 4:04 • ianireainara78 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
El joc no permitía realizar una accio i per aixo he perdido el torn i m ha perjudicat
6 aug 2023 5:36 • liliboum • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
alqays the same we can build
9 aug 2023 10:49 • sergut • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
There are six (6) reports on this bug report that some players have not been able to build a Settlement: HTDream (OP), boobookittyfrack, Anatoly Karpov, DopamineAddict, Hartley Ward, and ianireainara78 (and maybe liliboum...?).
From those, only two (2) provide references or screenshots so that the situation can be verified. In both cases, the issue is that they had run out of of Settlements, which is part of the rules. A player cannot have more than five (5) Settlements at any given time.
- HTDream: OP provides a reference to their game (Table #338413117, Move #141). I have followed the log and it is clear that the player had five (5) Settlements already (moves 4, 10, 90, 102, and 116) so they could not build more Settlements until they upgraded at least one of them to a City (which they did for the first time on move 170).
- Anatoly Karpov provides a screenshot to their game. It is evident from it that the player already has five (5) red Settlements, so they could not build more Settlements until they upgraded at least one of them to a City.
...
In short, this bug report does not report any bugs and should be closed.
From those, only two (2) provide references or screenshots so that the situation can be verified. In both cases, the issue is that they had run out of of Settlements, which is part of the rules. A player cannot have more than five (5) Settlements at any given time.
- HTDream: OP provides a reference to their game (Table #338413117, Move #141). I have followed the log and it is clear that the player had five (5) Settlements already (moves 4, 10, 90, 102, and 116) so they could not build more Settlements until they upgraded at least one of them to a City (which they did for the first time on move 170).
- Anatoly Karpov provides a screenshot to their game. It is evident from it that the player already has five (5) red Settlements, so they could not build more Settlements until they upgraded at least one of them to a City.
...
In short, this bug report does not report any bugs and should be closed.
23 aug 2023 18:36 • wolf333 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
No error message, just no option to build a settlement though there was a free space with a tleast two streets distance to everyone. Until now it happened the first time. I use browser Firefox.
23 aug 2023 18:37 • wolf333 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I did NOT run out of setllements!
23 aug 2023 18:38 • wolf333 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Ah, sorry. Maybe I had 5.
23 aug 2023 18:40 • wolf333 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
yes, indeed. I had 5 settlements at that moment.
29 aug 2023 16:24 • madandjolly • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Diese ist nicht das 1. Mal, dass ich keine Stadt bauen kann.
12 nov 2023 21:00 • ChineseUncle • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I tried building a settlement next to the robber hex but they didn't allow me. Right after my move the opponent was able to build at the same exact spot I wanted to build
24 dec 2023 9:34 • TanviJagtap • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Game ID 453605196
Did not allow me to build settlement.
Messed up UI.
Refreshed using control + shift + R.
I lost the same because of the bug.
It spoiled my statistics.
I am a premium member.
Fix this stupid bug.
The game is not worth playing
Did not allow me to build settlement.
Messed up UI.
Refreshed using control + shift + R.
I lost the same because of the bug.
It spoiled my statistics.
I am a premium member.
Fix this stupid bug.
The game is not worth playing
3 jan 2024 3:38 • deltaone9er • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
During game play, none of the players were able to build a settlement even when they had enough resources. It would only allow us to build roads and never settlements. Couldn’t finish the game.
27 jan 2024 22:45 • Dixy09 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
wanted to build a settlement. I had 1 left to build & yet it wasn't an available option
22 feb 2024 14:56 • K3lpi3 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I was just going to win by building a settlement, I had the resources and I had 9 points, and the play didn't let me build, the location was allowed, but the play didn't let me build. It has happened to me several times and it is not solved by pressing F5
22 feb 2024 17:03 • Dude78 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
When I have tried to créâtes à Settlement at port 3:1 on top, impossible Even if I try to move thé screen or un zoom It . It seems It’s due to the overlap of the Map icon.
My device: IPhone
Thanks
My device: IPhone
Thanks
29 apr 2024 17:39 • unicornlau • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Same as others. I had enough resources to build to possibly win the game. But would not let me build settlement and made me handicap the whole game and I had no choice to keep playing even though I knew I was just going to lose in the end. A slow annoying death because of this bug.
22 maj 2024 2:17 • Bleiz • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I had enough resources to build.
I take time to refresh, because i can't do anything else.
I was expel by others players
I take time to refresh, because i can't do anything else.
I was expel by others players
27 maj 2024 15:04 • leodu35 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Impossible de construire mes colonies
28 maj 2024 18:07 • Bgpopapmp1 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
This just happened to me in game 518221569. I had 4 settlements and a city on the board. I had enough resources to build a 5th settlement and a space to do it. My supply showed I had 0 settlements to build.
2 jun 2024 19:02 • thehighflyer • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Had enough resources to build a settlement but the button to do so did not appear. Was one point away from winning and ended with second place as a result of bug.
11 jun 2024 7:52 • the_calm_koala • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
At table number 523816001, player Rauling was not able to build a settlement even though they should have been able to build one -- the game said that they had no settlements left, failing to account for the settlement that they had upgraded to a city (even though it accounted for that for the rest of us who were playing).
14 jun 2024 19:59 • fredogonefishin • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Cities and knights.
Game glitched.
I had 4 settlements on the board but it wouldn't let me build a settlement.
imgur.com/bhoMeOe
Game glitched.
I had 4 settlements on the board but it wouldn't let me build a settlement.
imgur.com/bhoMeOe
17 jun 2024 4:02 • Aiosa • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Same thing happened tp me:
1. I had 2 cities and 4 settlements built. giving me one last settlement to build.
2. I had the necessary roads, spaces and resources to build but the game would not let me build my 5th settlement.
3. In my supply box it showed that I had no settlements left available to build, but i should have had one left.
4. I pressed F5 many many times, but it did not fix the situation.
5. Eventually i built another city then I was given one more settlement to build, but I should have had 2 by that time.
1. I had 2 cities and 4 settlements built. giving me one last settlement to build.
2. I had the necessary roads, spaces and resources to build but the game would not let me build my 5th settlement.
3. In my supply box it showed that I had no settlements left available to build, but i should have had one left.
4. I pressed F5 many many times, but it did not fix the situation.
5. Eventually i built another city then I was given one more settlement to build, but I should have had 2 by that time.
17 jun 2024 4:04 • Aiosa • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
526181967
F5 did not resolve the situation
the problem persisted for the rest of the game.
No screenshot
F5 did not resolve the situation
the problem persisted for the rest of the game.
No screenshot
17 jun 2024 20:08 • marconio • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I had 5 settlements.
After Building a city no settlement was added to my inventory.
I was not able to build a settlement because the number of available settlements was incorrectly set at 0 rather than 1.
After Building a city no settlement was added to my inventory.
I was not able to build a settlement because the number of available settlements was incorrectly set at 0 rather than 1.
17 jun 2024 20:10 • marconio • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
F5 did not solve the issue
This has happened to me before.
This has happened to me before.
23 jun 2024 21:00 • Shady_RED • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
CATAN #528532312
Played the add-on city & knights. My friend lose the city due to first barbarians.
Later on he rebuild the city, but was one off on the settlements count.
Is everything correctly counted in case of first city in the add-on that is given free compared to regular game?
Played the add-on city & knights. My friend lose the city due to first barbarians.
Later on he rebuild the city, but was one off on the settlements count.
Is everything correctly counted in case of first city in the add-on that is given free compared to regular game?
24 jun 2024 9:56 • Romocop • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
In a game with expansion. The game does not let me put my fifth settlement, nor does the token appear in the reserve. Despite complying with the rules, it only allows me to create a new knight in the space at the top right.
imgur.com/a/AIgGfNy
imgur.com/a/AIgGfNy
24 jun 2024 11:24 • Romocop • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
In this image it looks better because I no longer have resources for a knight but I do have resources for a settlement.
imgur.com/a/IHutX6x
imgur.com/a/IHutX6x
1 jul 2024 3:50 • taellis • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I see this issue is also reported here - boardgamearena.com/bug?id=127248
Report on issue from my game is there, same situiation, barbarians destroy initial city, when city is rebuilt you do not receive a settlement back.. In my case I built 2 cities and am now down to 3 settlement supply. Affects game play, please fix asap
Report on issue from my game is there, same situiation, barbarians destroy initial city, when city is rebuilt you do not receive a settlement back.. In my case I built 2 cities and am now down to 3 settlement supply. Affects game play, please fix asap
1 jul 2024 21:30 • taellis • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
update, move ~480 for blue built another city (total 3 now), this time a settlement was returned
1 jul 2024 21:31 • taellis • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
6 jul 2024 19:01 • EtnecivKroy • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
It happened again. Reloading the page did not solve the problem.
boardgamearena.com/11/catan?table=534041924
boardgamearena.com/11/catan?table=534041924
6 jul 2024 21:52 • Mathew5000 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
One of the reports above concerned table #453605196. I looked at the replay and it turns out, the player already had five settlements on the board. That is why the player could not build another settlement despite having the necessary resources and an otherwise valid intersection. Screencap (move 261): snipboard.io/0Ocozu.jpg The player's comment above says, "I lost the [game] because of the bug. It spoiled my statistics. I am a premium member. Fix this stupid bug." That was six months ago. Now when I click on the player's name I see a message stating "This player does not exist (account closed by player or for inactivity)".
It is really a shame that nobody ever explained to the player why the settlement could not be built. If I reported what I believed was a serious bug in a game and nobody ever responded, then I might feel disenchanted with the site and cancel my membership also.
It is really a shame that nobody ever explained to the player why the settlement could not be built. If I reported what I believed was a serious bug in a game and nobody ever responded, then I might feel disenchanted with the site and cancel my membership also.
6 jul 2024 23:12 • MISASEBAN • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
same problem as described, i built a city and a settlement should have appeared, but did not, and i stayed with only 4 settlements, no option to built the 5th one (i had ressources for).
8 jul 2024 17:01 • DavyCrockett • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
We just had the same issue at table #534780141, move 70. boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/240704-1002/?table=534780141&player=85514475&comments=88093863;&goto=69
(grabbed a screenshot from the replay imgur.com/a/PdSgXa3)
Orange has 4 settlements on board, but the UI shows 0 left, and they cannot build on the clay port.
F5 did not solve the problem
(grabbed a screenshot from the replay imgur.com/a/PdSgXa3)
Orange has 4 settlements on board, but the UI shows 0 left, and they cannot build on the clay port.
F5 did not solve the problem
8 jul 2024 17:06 • DavyCrockett • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
imgur.com/a/settlement-bug-P0QfwOb is the imgur link for my post above (messed it up somehow)
8 jul 2024 17:11 • DavyCrockett • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
And it was move 377, not 70 (I'm bad at this)
23 jul 2024 18:53 • Fruzia83 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
After I had 5 settlements built, I was changed one to the city. And I should have one settlement free in hand to use. But on my list was 0 and icon was gray/shaded. I had all the resources, available place, and game didn't allow me to place anything on the crossroad.
26 jul 2024 6:10 • Boggystyle • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Players info were in front of the buttons. Unable to confirm the build of. A settlement
6 aug 2024 3:53 • mudry_pavel • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
problem whole game
11 aug 2024 1:42 • ggb24 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Built a City, Settlement didnt return to inventory
14 aug 2024 17:00 • the_calm_koala • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
This happened to me as well, during table 549782186; I had 4 settlements and 1 city left, and all of the supplies to build a settlement, but was only given the option to build a knight. During a later turn, I moved the activated knight, and had the option to build a settlement. This only happened once during the game.
17 aug 2024 17:36 • Cfoize • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Impossible de construire pendant 5-6 tours déjà : seules touches actives, échange et passer…
27 aug 2024 19:04 • FromLardToHard • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I to had the same issues of 4 towns and the 5th one never came up for me to build anywhere.
f5 did not help.
I am brown in the image.
imgur.com/gallery/catan-problems-uuk8ofH
f5 did not help.
I am brown in the image.
imgur.com/gallery/catan-problems-uuk8ofH
28 aug 2024 22:08 • bsamh • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
SAME HAPPENED TO ME! I thought I was losing my mind or maybe an option was that someone got rid of my settlement but it said I only had 4 to place
30 aug 2024 17:16 • euklid314 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
boardgamearena.com/4/catan?table=556423792
The blue player lost a city and later had only 4 settlements available. He could not build his 5th settlement anymore.
The blue player lost a city and later had only 4 settlements available. He could not build his 5th settlement anymore.
7 sep 2024 2:18 • 1000Faces • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I upgraded a settlement to a city, house was not returned to me. could not build settlement in next action even though I would have another in my stock after replacing it with a city (was otherwise depleted of settlements)
13 sep 2024 6:35 • cboers18 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Table number 562029704
I had 2 cities and 4 settlements on the board. I had all the resources needed and two valid places to build a settlement. My inventory said I had no settlements left. Cities and Knights expansion. Refreshing did not help.
I had 2 cities and 4 settlements on the board. I had all the resources needed and two valid places to build a settlement. My inventory said I had no settlements left. Cities and Knights expansion. Refreshing did not help.
24 sep 2024 21:31 • LucyLuC • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I had built all of my settlements before building my first city. But it didnt give me the replaced settlement piece back. So when I tried to build another settlement shortly after the game did not give me the option to build as it did not think I had a free settlement to build, even tho I only have 4 settlements and one city on the board. I refreshed the page multiple times but this did nothing
Table #566976127, move 373
Chrome browser
Table #566976127, move 373
Chrome browser
28 sep 2024 20:52 • procrastist • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Happened for orange in game: boardgamearena.com/8/catan?table=568641374
F5 did not help
Settlement count for orange was off by −1 for the rest of the game.
Screenshot saved.
F5 did not help
Settlement count for orange was off by −1 for the rest of the game.
Screenshot saved.
10 okt 2024 23:39 • Valsss • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Same here... Build a city but settlement don't come back in my inventory
14 okt 2024 4:37 • JoseeFre • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Table : Catan 549810695
J’ai joué la carte construction de route et j’avais une route à placer. Lorsque je sélectionne l’emplacement, le message erreur inattendue: Unexpected final game state(50) (référence: GS14 12/10 18:00:50). J’ai essayé le cliqué ici si l’interface est instable ou bloqué ( je joue sur mon iphone11), j’ai fermé BGA, je me suis reconnecté, j’ai appuyé sur annuler mais je reste toujours bloqué à l’étape de sélection de route.
J’ai joué la carte construction de route et j’avais une route à placer. Lorsque je sélectionne l’emplacement, le message erreur inattendue: Unexpected final game state(50) (référence: GS14 12/10 18:00:50). J’ai essayé le cliqué ici si l’interface est instable ou bloqué ( je joue sur mon iphone11), j’ai fermé BGA, je me suis reconnecté, j’ai appuyé sur annuler mais je reste toujours bloqué à l’étape de sélection de route.
15 okt 2024 16:12 • Timmy222 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Reproduced the same issue playing Cities & Knights:
Table 575830395 move #310
I (Orange) tried to build a settlement, but the interface wouldn't allow me to even though I had a valid location (at the bottom; 9 sheep & 2 ore).
In the log, it says "Timmy222 has more than 5 settlements on board due to a previous pillage" but I had already upgraded one to a city, and so I only had 4 settlements on the board.
Table 575830395 move #310
I (Orange) tried to build a settlement, but the interface wouldn't allow me to even though I had a valid location (at the bottom; 9 sheep & 2 ore).
In the log, it says "Timmy222 has more than 5 settlements on board due to a previous pillage" but I had already upgraded one to a city, and so I only had 4 settlements on the board.
2 nov 2024 4:52 • Arctic Puma • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
reproduction:
Table #579608263; current turn #495 issue probably occurred around #475 or before but couldn't go back that far in the history.
F5 did not solve the issue
Frequency Unknown but seems often given the response.
imgur.com/a/XfAXifU
Table #579608263; current turn #495 issue probably occurred around #475 or before but couldn't go back that far in the history.
F5 did not solve the issue
Frequency Unknown but seems often given the response.
imgur.com/a/XfAXifU
4 nov 2024 23:57 • Lily23 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
boardgamearena.com/11/catan?table=584724486 (Player White)
Same issue as reported. Lost my City first time Barbarians attacked. Rebuilt. Did not notice that my settlement count didn't replenish. Went to build my 5th settlement (legal spot, all resources) and nothing happened. No error messages or anything.
Same issue as reported. Lost my City first time Barbarians attacked. Rebuilt. Did not notice that my settlement count didn't replenish. Went to build my 5th settlement (legal spot, all resources) and nothing happened. No error messages or anything.
13 nov 2024 0:16 • iamhrlyquin • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
What was the game action you wanted to do?
wanted to build a settlement. I had 1 left to build & yet it wasn't an available option. I had 4 settlements & 1 city built at the time
• What did you try to do to trigger this game action?
Clicked on build
• What happened when you tried to do this (error message, game status bar message, ...)?
No error message, just no option to build a settlement
F5 did not solve the problem, refreshed, reloaded the game, look at the final screen, ty
wanted to build a settlement. I had 1 left to build & yet it wasn't an available option. I had 4 settlements & 1 city built at the time
• What did you try to do to trigger this game action?
Clicked on build
• What happened when you tried to do this (error message, game status bar message, ...)?
No error message, just no option to build a settlement
F5 did not solve the problem, refreshed, reloaded the game, look at the final screen, ty
15 nov 2024 21:14 • mcbradleypants • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
F5 did not solve the problem,
When barbarians pillaged to a settlement and I rebuilt a city I did not get the settlement back and played the end of the game with 4 settlements instead of 5
When barbarians pillaged to a settlement and I rebuilt a city I did not get the settlement back and played the end of the game with 4 settlements instead of 5
17 nov 2024 15:17 • FloppyBod • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I have the same issue
17 nov 2024 19:01 • 96882519 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I have 2 cities and 3 settlements, it didn't allow me to build a new settlement, it didn't show I have free settlement to build, other players could build enough settlement
23 nov 2024 4:18 • Red Admiral • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I had 4 settlements built but it didn't show my 5th settlement in available resources and wouldn't let me build it.
11 dec 2024 12:43 • procrastist • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Just curious what more info is needed. It is a simple arithmetic bug. It should be as easy as adding some test cases and fix the code so that they pass. Plenty of links to games where it happened have been posted.
21 dec 2024 18:25 • Timmy222 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Reproduced again. The issue is that when Barbarians pillage a city and turn it back into a settlement, the counters are not correctly maintained. When I tried to build a settlement later in the game, and only had 4 settlements in play, I was unable to.
See move 284 in game boardgamearena.com/table?table=604613168
Also note the message in the log at move 273, which is wrong due to the counter not being correct:
Timmy222 has more than 5 settlements on board due to a previous pillage
Note that this affected the player winning order, as I would've come in second instead of tying for second in this game.
See move 284 in game boardgamearena.com/table?table=604613168
Also note the message in the log at move 273, which is wrong due to the counter not being correct:
Timmy222 has more than 5 settlements on board due to a previous pillage
Note that this affected the player winning order, as I would've come in second instead of tying for second in this game.
1 jan 2025 13:13 • EERHARD • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Ich konnte keine Siedlung an einem Knotenpunkt von meiner und der Straße eines Gegners setzen und im nächsten Zug war die Zählung der längsten Straße falsch . Meine Straße hatte 9 und die des Gegners 6 und er hat mit längster Handelsstraße gewonnen
1 jan 2025 22:22 • procrastist • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
If you keep playing with such a game breaking bug they might not bother fixing it. Be patient and do something else until it is fixed.
8 jan 2025 14:14 • Airballzed • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
imgur.com/a/wA1B8y6
Same problem and it's not the first time (im blue on screen)
I've built 5 colonies and have 0 available. Then I upgrade a colony in town and the colony doesn't go back into my “bank”. I update, but nothing happens. If you look at my screenshot, you can see that I'm missing a colony, and the next move, i have the resources and the location available but the game doesn't allowed me the “build a colony” action because the game considers that I have none available.
Good luck,
bye
Same problem and it's not the first time (im blue on screen)
I've built 5 colonies and have 0 available. Then I upgrade a colony in town and the colony doesn't go back into my “bank”. I update, but nothing happens. If you look at my screenshot, you can see that I'm missing a colony, and the next move, i have the resources and the location available but the game doesn't allowed me the “build a colony” action because the game considers that I have none available.
Good luck,
bye
8 jan 2025 18:31 • SvenOver • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
boardgamearena.com/8/catan?table=612485560, move #213, blue player (=me)
F5 didn't solve the problem
imgur.com/a/Pia8u0z
Earlier i had lost my city due to barbarian attack. Now my total number of settlements is 4 instead of 5.
I got to know that when in the situation in the imgur URL above, i wanted to build a 5th settlement at the brick port: there was no option to do that, the game automatically placed a knight instead of a settlement.
F5 didn't solve the problem
imgur.com/a/Pia8u0z
Earlier i had lost my city due to barbarian attack. Now my total number of settlements is 4 instead of 5.
I got to know that when in the situation in the imgur URL above, i wanted to build a 5th settlement at the brick port: there was no option to do that, the game automatically placed a knight instead of a settlement.
18 jan 2025 0:02 • JaanaL • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Could not build settlement on allowed location while having all resources. Interface showed that i only had 4 settlements, other players had 5 available. This had significant negative effect on my game.
20 jan 2025 8:00 • GamerOne264 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Cities and knights.
Game glitched.
I had 4 settlements on the board but it wouldn't let me build a settlement.
imgur.com/a/G1lwfp7
Game glitched.
I had 4 settlements on the board but it wouldn't let me build a settlement.
imgur.com/a/G1lwfp7
23 jan 2025 22:13 • LucyLuC • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
This has also happened to me in multiple games. Most recently game #619747569
It seems to happen when I lose a city earlier in the game due to the barbarians, and then continue to build only settlements until I have used all of my settlements. But aster upgrading one to a city the original settlement piece is not returned to my inventory which then blocks me from rightfully building another settlement until I have built a second city
Refreshing the page has never solved this issue
It seems to happen when I lose a city earlier in the game due to the barbarians, and then continue to build only settlements until I have used all of my settlements. But aster upgrading one to a city the original settlement piece is not returned to my inventory which then blocks me from rightfully building another settlement until I have built a second city
Refreshing the page has never solved this issue
26 jan 2025 21:16 • EvgeniaDe • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I can't build roads and buildings
11 feb 2025 4:26 • tomo084 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
The same bug is happening with the cities and knights rule. (I built 5 settlements, then built a city, but the settlements never came back)
boardgamearena.com/10/catan?table=616771339
boardgamearena.com/10/catan?table=616771339
11 feb 2025 12:39 • pavlo925 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
same, i have 4 settlements and i cant build 5
17 feb 2025 16:50 • Shinko94 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I have the resources but it doesn't let me acquire the economic, political and scientific sectors
I have the resources but it doesn't let me acquire the economic, political and scientific sectors
24 feb 2025 22:54 • strippedtigers • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
table: 635180520
F5 didn't solve.
I had 5 villages built, turned one into the city. I couldn't build after this a village, neither in the next turns.
F5 didn't solve.
I had 5 villages built, turned one into the city. I couldn't build after this a village, neither in the next turns.
25 feb 2025 3:27 • llillilllill • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
No villages built. No 5 villages built.
27 feb 2025 21:56 • signefied • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
I ran out of settlements, when I upgraded the settlement to city, the settlement stayed hovering on the game board. It didn't go back to supply. After refresh it did, but i could not build it. Opponent had the same thing, just couldnt build the last settlement.
28 feb 2025 11:09 • nouna7blue • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
the game blocked me from building a road at first then after refresh I literally couldn't do ANYTHING
2 mar 2025 1:29 • katemac68 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Unable to build settlement. Corner piece. I ensured there were two spaces, and I had enough settlement pieces. Move 163.
(This also happened in a previous game. Unable to build road at corner piece, but opponent was able to build there on their next move. I don't remember game number)
(This also happened in a previous game. Unable to build road at corner piece, but opponent was able to build there on their next move. I don't remember game number)
4 mar 2025 5:22 • Artivis • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Same issue there - had 4 settlements and 1 city built - 2 open spots to build a 5th settlement but would not let me build it
imgur.com/a/pXrTJRU
imgur.com/a/pXrTJRU
8 mar 2025 7:00 • MrOC • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
Table #637256992
Move #327
Progression 55%
BGA blocked me from building a Settlement on "8 Wood Hex" at the 3:1 Harbor, but allowed me to build roads to location on "8 Sheep Hex" at different 3:1 Harbor & then build a Settlement there.
Not sure if this context matters, but the initial block happened right after I had activated & move the Knight that had been located at the "8 Wood Hex" at the 3:1 Harbor.
So far the problem has only appeared this one time, but it has ruined my "Grand Plan" for Victory...
Move #327
Progression 55%
BGA blocked me from building a Settlement on "8 Wood Hex" at the 3:1 Harbor, but allowed me to build roads to location on "8 Sheep Hex" at different 3:1 Harbor & then build a Settlement there.
Not sure if this context matters, but the initial block happened right after I had activated & move the Knight that had been located at the "8 Wood Hex" at the 3:1 Harbor.
So far the problem has only appeared this one time, but it has ruined my "Grand Plan" for Victory...
23 mar 2025 5:00 • Taj1 • Mer information efterfrågas av utvecklarna för att kunna återskapa detta fel:
it has happened twice/ i noticed it inly happened after a city became pillaged
Lägg till något till denna rapport
Lägg till här allt som verkar relevant för att reproducera det här felet eller förstå ditt förslag:
- Ett annat spelbords-ID / drag-ID
- Löste F5 problemet?
- Uppträdde problemet flera gånger? Varje gång? Slumpmässigt?
- Om du har en skärmdump av denna buggen (vilket är bra), så kan du använda Imgur.com för att ladda upp den och kopiera/klistra in länken här.
