Rapportera • Board Game Arena

Alla rapporter

Gaia Project rapporter

#95960: "Players who already passed are charging power automatically"

open: Buggen har inte kunnat återupprepas av utvecklarna än

Vad handlar denna rapport om?

Gaia Project #407391208

Vad hände? Välj från alternativen nedan

Regler: en av spelets regler har inte respekterats

Vad hände? Välj från alternativen nedan

Regler: en av spelets regler har inte respekterats

Vänligen kontrollera om det redan finns en rapport om samma ämne

Om detta stämmer, RÖSTA på denna rapport. Rapporterna med flest röster har PRIORITET!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Detaljerad beskrivning

Rapporthistorik

15 Aug 2023 05:52 • evilhippo12 • Buggen har inte kunnat återupprepas av utvecklarna än:

This bug could give a player more points than they should have. In this game the Itars recieved 1 more point than they should have because the power was then converted at the end of the game.

15 Aug 2023 06:05 • Kayvon • Detta är ingen bugg:

Theyre allowed to passive charge even after passing. You seem to believe otherwise -- could I trouble you tocite the rulebook passage that backs up your claim?

15 Aug 2023 20:53 • evilhippo12 • Detta är ingen bugg:

Ok I guess the part that doesn’t follow the rules is: conversions of power to credits happen at the end of the game after you pass. It should happen right at passing.

The rulebook says on page 16 under 9) Free Actions “You cannot take a free action if it is not your turn (e.g., if you already passed, during a passive action, during a different phase, etc.).”

Even if they are allowed to charge power after passing in round 6, they shouldn’t be able to convert it.

15 Aug 2023 21:02 • Kayvon • Detta är ingen bugg:

Good clarifications. Originally, no automated conversions occurred after the game ended. After overwhelming (and vehement) player feedback, we added the automation.

I'm in favor with eliminating that automation, but not for the amout of hate mail I will get for doing so. Consequently, I'll leave this as-is.

5 Oct 2023 00:01 • evilhippo12 • Detta är ingen bugg:

I understand the players' want for automation. But, couldn't the timing of the automation change to at the time of passing? This would follow the rules, while still having automation occur.

5 Oct 2023 22:23 • Kayvon • Buggen har inte kunnat återupprepas av utvecklarna än:

Yes, that would solve the problem from a technical standpoint, but probably still result in hate mail.

I'm not eager to volunteer for work that I know will bring in hate mail, but I'll open this to votes to gauge interest anyway.

19 Dec 2023 22:19 • orangeglacier • Buggen har inte kunnat återupprepas av utvecklarna än:

Why would people have a strong opinion whether you automatically convert when they pass for the last time or at the actual end of the game? It would make no difference to the result (or if it would, it's because the current implementation would produce an inaccurate result as in this bug report). With that change, you could also remove any prompts for player X to charge power after player X has passed, which would speed up async games and resolve a few current suggestions.

21 Feb 2025 00:15 • Skullblaca • Buggen har inte kunnat återupprepas av utvecklarna än:

According to this old thread on bgg, which includes one of the authors of Gaia Project (Helge Ostertag), charging and even converting power to VPs after the final passing and before the final scoring is allowed and intended (just not properly written in the rulebook):
boardgamegeek.com/thread/1906815/final-resource-scoring

Therefore, this is not a bug, but according to the rules. This bug report can be closed.

Lägg till något till denna rapport

Lägg till här allt som verkar relevant för att reproducera det här felet eller förstå ditt förslag:

Ett annat spelbords-ID / drag-ID
Löste F5 problemet?
Uppträdde problemet flera gånger? Varje gång? Slumpmässigt?
Om du har en skärmdump av den här buggen (bra vana att ta en), så kan du använda en programvara (snipboard.io som till exempel) för att ladda upp bilden och klistra in länken här.

Avbryt Uppdatera rapport

#95960: "Players who already passed are charging power automatically"

Vad handlar denna rapport om?

Vad hände? Välj från alternativen nedan

Vad hände? Välj från alternativen nedan

Vänligen kontrollera om det redan finns en rapport om samma ämne

Detaljerad beskrivning

Rapporthistorik

Lägg till något till denna rapport

Ändra rapportstatus till:

Hjälp

Bidra

Navigera

Följ oss