Alla rapporter
Space Base rapporter
#42349: "Auto pick options should be the default in turn-based games"
implemented: Detta förslag har implementerats
184
Vad handlar denna rapport om?
Vad hände? Välj från alternativen nedan
Förslag: Enligt min åsikt så skulle följande förbättra spelimplementationen mycket
Detaljerad beskrivning
• Vänligen förklara ditt förslag exakt och koncist så att det är så enkelt som möjligt att förstå vad du menar.
Please have "on" and "better" be the default choices for all players in turn-based games. Right now we all have to turn them on for every new game.• Vad har du för webbläsare?
Google Chrome v90
Rapporthistorik
13 jun 2021 18:40 • towehaal • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
Totally agree with this. I can’t think of a good reason it should not be the default option.
25 jun 2021 18:28 • CanuckEddie • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
I don't know about default - people should really know what they are getting into before they are using it - but if they could PLEASE carry over from game to game that would be delightful.
(I honestly can't think of a good reason to not use them as default to be clear, but it should be an informed choice not a bewildering series of automated actions for new players)
(I honestly can't think of a good reason to not use them as default to be clear, but it should be an informed choice not a bewildering series of automated actions for new players)
18 aug 2021 20:22 • theaarondean • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
Definitely agree with this suggestion for turn-based, or at least implement a way for a player's settings to be saved between games.
25 aug 2021 13:21 • Joseph2302 • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
A game with a user not using the auto pick options will be incredibly slow. Is there a way to make this an option on game setup, so that everyone has to use the auto pick options?
28 dec 2021 20:43 • martang • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
At the very least, a person should be able to set their own preference as a default.
12 jan 2022 21:11 • Dorian Gray2 • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
I definately agree. It is annoying to turn it on every time.
6 feb 2022 1:31 • alexsim • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
I agree with this suggestion, but I would go further, and set the default to use auto-pick for all games.
The log makes it quite clear what is going on, so I think do not think new players will be confused. (Like me, they are probably reluctant to turn on *any* options in their first game.) Also, the "or better" logic works quite well, so users don't need to be afraid of using it.
The log makes it quite clear what is going on, so I think do not think new players will be confused. (Like me, they are probably reluctant to turn on *any* options in their first game.) Also, the "or better" logic works quite well, so users don't need to be afraid of using it.
26 mar 2022 22:46 • Wentu • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
Totally agree: it is already really clear what happens from turn to turn.
One thing though, maybe worth of a different ticket: the "BETTER" algorithm definitely CAN be improved.
Several time I have choices like "2 coins + 1 coins" OR "3 coins and 1 point". The second one is clearly better but the "better" option doesn't kick in to speed up the game.
The algorithm pseudo code should be something like:
1) subtract, reward-wise, one choice from the other (coin-coin, points-points, revenue-revenue, specialActionTypeN-specialActionTypeN
2) if all the differences come out 0, choose one automatically since they are the same
3) if only one comes out different from 0, choose the one with that larger value
4) if two or more differences are different from 0, leave the choice to the player
One thing though, maybe worth of a different ticket: the "BETTER" algorithm definitely CAN be improved.
Several time I have choices like "2 coins + 1 coins" OR "3 coins and 1 point". The second one is clearly better but the "better" option doesn't kick in to speed up the game.
The algorithm pseudo code should be something like:
1) subtract, reward-wise, one choice from the other (coin-coin, points-points, revenue-revenue, specialActionTypeN-specialActionTypeN
2) if all the differences come out 0, choose one automatically since they are the same
3) if only one comes out different from 0, choose the one with that larger value
4) if two or more differences are different from 0, leave the choice to the player
29 apr 2022 5:01 • Tanjanica • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
100% agree with this. Or at least let people set defaults like they do in other games.
29 apr 2022 23:19 • lucreciiaa • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
I think the auto should be defaulted to "ON" and "Only one"
I don't want the computer picking what is "best" for me.
but it should NOT default to "off" for sure!
I don't want the computer picking what is "best" for me.
but it should NOT default to "off" for sure!
6 maj 2022 22:28 • GawainNO • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
Or at least make it remember it as a setting per user.
10 maj 2022 12:12 • Ginso • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
Yes make it a game option
18 maj 2022 15:29 • Joe • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
I agree, this could be best set during Game creation, so that a player knows what he is getting into. But still leave it selectable in the Game preferences afterwards.
29 maj 2022 5:03 • Santa-The-Hutt • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
Allow the setting to persist across games would be great. Making it the default would probably be bad for new players who need to get used to the game and how choices are made first.
> Several time I have choices like "2 coins + 1 coins" OR "3 coins and 1 point". The second one is clearly better but the "better" option doesn't kick in to speed up the game.
I'm not sure this is universally better. I think there might be an edge case where, if you trigger game end this way, it might deprive you of a turn you would otherwise have had, and thus allow someone else to win.
> Several time I have choices like "2 coins + 1 coins" OR "3 coins and 1 point". The second one is clearly better but the "better" option doesn't kick in to speed up the game.
I'm not sure this is universally better. I think there might be an edge case where, if you trigger game end this way, it might deprive you of a turn you would otherwise have had, and thus allow someone else to win.
25 jul 2022 13:49 • PirateKitten • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
Another upvote! It's a fantastic implementation currently, and the only thing I'm wishing from it is that it carried over my settings between games.
I agree with idea of not making it default, just to remember the settings as player preferences.
I agree with idea of not making it default, just to remember the settings as player preferences.
1 sep 2022 5:02 • xone01 • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
Please for the love of Games can we fix this? At the very least remember preferences like sooooooo many other games do
2 sep 2022 14:48 • Phoxtrot • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
Yeah, I agree that remembering the preference is probably better than changing the default.
But current situation is not optimal and changing the default should be very simple to implement.
But current situation is not optimal and changing the default should be very simple to implement.
14 dec 2022 1:12 • ShibbaCha • Detta förslag har inte analyserats av utvecklarna ännu :
No updates on this? Are the developers just not caring about maintaining?
14 dec 2022 1:52 • Shazzypaz • Utvecklare håller med om att det är en bra idé, och tänker jobba på den:
ShibbaCha - the original developers had not been maintaining the game. I took over maintenance of the game a few weeks ago in order to fix at least the worst bugs. I am aware of this request and will consider it once more of the bugs are fixed.
10 feb 2023 16:35 • King Hrothbeort • Utvecklare håller med om att det är en bra idé, och tänker jobba på den:
I think the default for all games should be "On" and "Only One". Allowing players to set their own defaults that carryover from game to game would also be fine, though likely harder to code.
15 apr 2024 14:59 • dralkyr • Utvecklare håller med om att det är en bra idé, och tänker jobba på den:
This was reported in 2022 and it's now 2 years later. Can we please please get this implemented?
15 apr 2024 15:38 • greenjacket124 • Utvecklare håller med om att det är en bra idé, och tänker jobba på den:
This honestly should not be the default at all. The default should be the options that help you learn the game. Everyone who has played a few times and is used to the game select these options, anyway.
18 aug 2024 13:38 • Jeno73 • Utvecklare håller med om att det är en bra idé, och tänker jobba på den:
I don't want to choose between beginners and advanced players, but I think we don't have to.
I am going to pick this up soon, in a bit different fashion.
1) these settings will be inherited from your previous game, so you don't have to set it every time.
2) I am considering a game mode, in which the fast mode will be enforced on all players.
Let me know if that would do it.
I am going to pick this up soon, in a bit different fashion.
1) these settings will be inherited from your previous game, so you don't have to set it every time.
2) I am considering a game mode, in which the fast mode will be enforced on all players.
Let me know if that would do it.
18 aug 2024 18:58 • Jeno73 • Utvecklare håller med om att det är en bra idé, och tänker jobba på den:
> 1) these settings will be inherited from your previous game, so you don't have to set it every time.
so this is what I planned, but when I tried, I learned a lot about how bga actually works.
so for now, I added a Preference that you can set. (using the three gray horizontal lines in top top right corner)
it is called: "Fast options are default"
Let me know if it fullfills the requested feature
so this is what I planned, but when I tried, I learned a lot about how bga actually works.
so for now, I added a Preference that you can set. (using the three gray horizontal lines in top top right corner)
it is called: "Fast options are default"
Let me know if it fullfills the requested feature
24 aug 2024 7:21 • fruitier • Utvecklare håller med om att det är en bra idé, och tänker jobba på den:
Not the original reporter but I love the new "Fast options are default" flag, exactly what I always wanted!
Lägg till något till denna rapport
Lägg till här allt som verkar relevant för att reproducera det här felet eller förstå ditt förslag:
- Ett annat spelbords-ID / drag-ID
- Löste F5 problemet?
- Uppträdde problemet flera gånger? Varje gång? Slumpmässigt?
- Om du har en skärmdump av denna buggen (vilket är bra), så kan du använda Imgur.com för att ladda upp den och kopiera/klistra in länken här.
